Skip to main content

WEEK 12: COMICS BY WOMEN

Image result for This one summer"


I have seen this comic at B&N multiple times and considered picking it up, but I was never able to sit down and read through it. Considering how much I loved reading “Blankets,” I had a feeling that I was going to like this week’s reading a lot. I think that “This One Summer” by Mariko and Jillian Tamaki is like a sweet love letter to our prepubescent years. I enjoyed the topics that were highlighted in the story, like the pregnancy and random girl talks between Rose and Windy. It’s nice to see someone out there starting the conversation about these “taboo topics,” and to use comics as a form of communication is engaging for all ages. The story had a good pacing throughout, and I liked how it didn’t feel like a fictional piece of work. It felt more like a summertime memoir, and the art complemented that feeling wonderfully. Jillian’s art style was simply beautiful; the lines were very organic and clean, making the whole page cohesive. Though the comic was all done in line work, there is a softness present that enhances the idyllic nature of Awago. The graphic shading also made the drawings pop more.
Though I enjoyed the story, I can’t say that it felt relatable to me personally. I think that is just because I’ve never gone to summer camp, or my camping trips weren’t as dramatic/ adventurous as Rose and Windy. However, the attention to detail and specificity to each moment brought in a familiar feeling. It made me wish that I had a childhood best friend that I would go to the store with, or watch horror films that were way too scary for our age group. All the subtle nuances in the characters, whether it was their dialogue or the poses, felt more realistic to me rather than a cliché 2D character. I feel like I knew someone like Windy, or even “The Dud.”
Overall, I would highly recommend this book. I read that several schools banned it in 2016 for having mature themes. Though I agree that some parts can be deemed as “inappropriate” for elementary school kids, but it really shouldn’t have been questioned for middle/ high schoolers. It is important to learn and be exposed to sensitive topics at an earlier age, and the way that the book addressed them were in a tasteful manner. Regardless, I still believe that preteens, especially girls, should take some time to experience “This One Summer.”

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

WEEK 2: UNDERSTANDING COMICS

This week I read Understanding Comics by Scott McCloud, and it was quite an eye-opening experience. At first I thought the book would be more of a history lesson, going through famous comics through the years almost like a textbook. However, McCloud provided something much more insightful than that. He was able to explain the structure, iconography, style, pipeline, and so much more all in approximately 200 pages. I really enjoyed the structure of the book as well—teaching about the world of comics in the form of a comic. This visual approach really helped to carry his points across the page in a simple, fun way. The pacing of his lecture was well-written too, being informative but also captivating. I learned a lot of new terms and ideas from McCloud, but I really enjoyed reading about the different transitions used in comics. It is interesting to note that the vast majority of Western comics primarily use 3 out of 6 transitions (action, subject, and scene), with act...
Post a Comment
Read more

WEEK 14: COMICS TODAY

There is a huge audience for web comics nowadays, which made me feel that they were appropriate to discuss for this week’s blogpost. In South Korea especially, there is a whole sub-culture of webtoon artists and readers. Some become insanely popular, which often lead to big hit television remakes of the comic (also true in Japan). What’s interesting about online comics is the amount of variety for me, as I can easily switch from a very emotional, dramatic story to slice-of-life comedic one shots. Websites like Line Webtoon, Lehzin, or Comico make it extremely easy and convenient to jump from one series to the next. It also brings an opportunity for aspiring comic artists to showcase their talents, and possibly gain a huge following. I wanted to highlight three different web comics today: “Lore Olympus” by Rachel Smythe, “Ghost Teller” by QTT, and “Sarah’s Scribbles” by Sarah Andersen. These select three are extremely different from each other, but they are al...
Post a Comment
Read more

WEEK 15: WIDE WORLD OF COMICS (REVISED FROM WEEK 9)

For my last blogpost, I decided to revise my week 9 blogpost where I discussed “Pyongyang.” After reading through it again, I thought that I didn’t give as much personal insight into it compared to my other blogposts. So, here we go again: “Pyongyang: A Journey in North Korea” by Guy Delisle was the retelling of his experience living in North Korea for two months. Rather than being a journal or diary, the narrative style felt like a really long, traditional comic strip. The storytelling had similarities to “Maus” because of the non-fictional content. However, it was not as captivating and visually impactful as “Maus.” To be honest, I think I was expecting something more from this comic. I wanted to feel enlightened and moved, and walk away from this comic with a new perspective on this country. It was partially my fault for having these high expectations, but overall I did find this comic to be an interesting read. I probably wouldn’t remember it after a while, but I...
Post a Comment
Read more